RADICAL TRANSFORMATIONS OF POLITICAL VALUES IN THE STATES OF CENTRAL AND EASTERN EUROPE DURING THE POLITICAL AND ECONOMIC TRANSITION OF THE LATE 1980-s AND EARLY 1990-s
Abstract
The article analyzes the changes that took place in public consciousness during the political and economic transition in the states of Central-Eastern Europe as a result of the fall of totalitarian communist regimes and the formation of a democratic system. Special attention is paid to the transformation of political values (welfare, freedom, equality, security). The loss of economic and ideological legitimacy of the communist regimes, their collapse lead to the widespread dissemination of a new system of values in society, but at the same time to social anomie, when new individual values contradicts with the old ones.
It was found that the concept of well-being began to be perceived to a greater extent through the prism of the market economy, private initiative, integration into the EU, at the same time significant paternalistic attitudes were preserved, which affected the privatization processes in particular. Ideas of economic equality remained popular, although to a greater extent in the form of state redistribution of profits, but income differentiation was increasingly perceived as a necessary stimulus for successful economic development. In security matters, the idea of integration into NATO and the EU, under the condition of maximum preservation of national sovereignty, became dominant. The idea of stability gave way to the value of development, sometimes even revolutionary. The value of order began to be interpreted through the prism of democratic views, including free elections and a multi-party system, although differences in the political culture of different states caused different results of the implementation of democratic principles: they were more successful in the states of Central Europe, less successful in the Balkan states. The vast majority of the population of the states of Central and Eastern Europe were rapidly moving away from the Marxist interpretation of the value of freedom, now understanding it as limiting state intervention in the personal and public life of the individual.
The intensity of value transformations in different countries of the region is compared: the greatest changes for that period were experienced in Central Europe (Czech Republic, Poland, Hungary, Slovakia, Slovenia), while in Southeastern Europe (Serbia, Bulgaria, Albania, Romania) society turned out to be more polarized by value beliefs. Thanks to such cardinal changes in public attitudes, the countries of Central Europe went through the predominantly peaceful path of political and economic transformations of the 1990s. Whereas in South-Eastern Europe, where a value consensus in society had not been formed, the transformations were accompanied by instability and frequent upheavals.
Social stratification also affected the differences in value orientations: political elites, intelligentsia, businessmen were more prone to transformation of views, while workers, peasants, pensioners often maintained loyalty to the official values of the communist era or changed them partially and very slowly. In conditions of general growth of social anomie, value changes were unstable and could quickly roll back under unfavorable circumstances.
References
Politics . – 1993. – Vol. 5 (2). – P. 231-252.
Almond G. A., Powell G. B. Evaluating Political Goods and Productivity // International Political Science Review. -
1982. - Vol. 3, No. 2. – P. 173-181.
Barjaba K. Albania in Transition: Elite’s Role and Perspective. - Tirana, 1998. - 54 р.
Comparative Politics Today: A World View / Ed. By G. B. Powell, R. J. Dalton, K. W. Strom. - Harlow: Pearson, 2015. –
769 p.
Ethridge M. E., Handelman H. Politics in a Changing World: A Comparative Introduction to Political Science. - Boston:
Wadsworth, 2010. - 657 p.
McCloskey H. J. Human Needs, Rights and Political Values // American Philosophical Quarterly. – 1976. - Vol. 13, No.
1. – P. 1-11.
Miller W. L., White S., Heywood P. Values and Political Change in Postcommunist Europe. – Ipswich: Macmillan Press,
1998. – 483 p.
World Values Survey 1990 / World Values Survey Association. - URL: https://www.worldvaluessurvey.org/WVSDocumentationWV2.jsp
World Values Survey 1995 / World Values Survey Association. - URL: https://www.worldvaluessurvey.org/WVSDocumentationWV3.jsp
Baltserovich L. “Dlya ekonomicheskih reform vsegda ochen vajen politicheskiy smyisl” / L. Baltserovich // Zerkalo
nedeli. - 1997. - № 14. - S. 1, 10.
Adamskiy V. Dinamika strukturnogo konflikta v hode smenyi sistemyi: Polsha v 1980-2000 gg. / V. Adamskiy, V. Zaborovskiy, K. Pelchinska-Nalench // Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya. - 2002. - № 6. - S. 50-62
Andreyko V. І. Problemi ekonomіchnoї іntegratsії Slovatskoї Respublіki do Єvropeyskogo Soyuzu / V. І. Andreyko //
Naukovі zapiski NaUKMA. - 2009. - T. 91: Іstorichnі nauki. - S. 58-62.
Belyaev E. V. Transformatsiya: u kajdoy stranyi unikalnyiy put / E. V. Belyaev // Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya. -
2002. - № 10. - S. 37-46.
Bogomolov O. T. Pervyie uroki ekonomicheskoy transformatsii v stranah TSentralnoy i Vostochnoy Evropyi 90-h gg. /
O. T. Bogomolov, S. P. Glinkina // Novaya i noveyshaya istoriya. - 1997. - № 3. - S. 6-20.
Boytsova V. V. Evropeyskiy soyuz: rasshirenie na vostok / V. V. Boytsova, L. V. Boytsova // Obschestvennyie nauki i
sovremennost. - 2002. - № 2. - S. 78-87.
Brusilovska O. І. SHlyahi ekonomіchnoї transformatsії CHehії ta Ugorschini naprikіntsі XX - na pochatku XXI st. / O.
І. Brusilovska // Vіsnik Odeskogo natsіonalnogo unіversitetu. - Serіya: Sotsіologіya, polіtologіya. - 2006. - T. 11. - Vip.
10. - S. 326-336.
Bunchak YA. Sotsiokulturnaya transformatsiya v Slovakii 1990-h gg. (nekotoryie itogi) / YA. Bunchak // Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya. - 2004. - № 7. - S. 115-119.
Buharin N. I. Polsha: desyat let po puti reform / N. I. Buharin, I. S. Sinitsina, N. A. CHudakova // Novaya i noveyshaya istoriya. - 2000. - № 4. - S. 38-57.
Valeva E. L. Transformatsionnyie protsessyi v Bolgarii 1944-1990 gg.: perehod k sotsializmu po sovetskomu obraztsu i povorot k evropeyskoy modeli razvitiya / E. L. Valeva // Vlast - obschestvo - reformyi: TSentralnaya i Yugo-Vostochnaya Evropa: 2-aya pol. HH v./ In-t slavyanovedeniya RAN; otv. red. E. G. Zadorojnyuk. - Moskva: Nauka, 2006. - S. 78-138.
Vasileva E. P. Dinamika sotsialnoy strukturyi v Polshe: izmenenie strategii i mesta sotsialnyih grupp v obschestve / E. P. Vasileva, L. S. Lyikoshina // Sotsialnyie i gumanitarnyie nauki: Otechestvennaya i zarubejnaya literatura. - Seriya 11: Sotsiologiya. - 2002. - № 2. - S. 46-62.
Verchenov L. N. [Retsenziya] / L. N. Verchenov. - Rets. na kn.: Denchev K. Vostochnaya Evropa posle sotsializma: poisk novyih paradigm (na primere Bolgarii) / K. Denchev // Sotsialnyie i gumanitarnyie nauki: Otechestvennaya i zarubejnaya literatura. - Seriya 4: Gosudarstvo i pravo. - 1998. - № 2. - S. 35-41.
Vodichka K. Razdel CHehoslovakii - desyat let spustya / K. Vodichka // Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya. - 2003. - № 10. - S. 129-134.
Vodopivets P. Sloventsyi mejdu Gerderom i Gegelem / P. Vodopivets // Vestnik Evropyi. - 2002. - № 5. - S. 44-46.
Vyatr E. Mestnyie elityi i demokraticheskie peremenyi: Polsha 1990-2002 / E. Vyatr // Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya. - 2005. - № 2. - S. 15-21.
Grushetskiy B. P. Stanovlennya єvroatlantichnogo vektoru zovnіshnoї polіtiki Bolgarії u kontekstі zabezpechennya natsіonalnoї bezpeki kraїni / B. P. Grushetskiy // Transatlantichna bezpeka ta rol Ukraїni: Mat-li Vseukr. nauk.-prakt. konf. — Dnіpropetrovsk: Іnnovatsіya, 2015. — S. 20-23.
Guskova E. YU. Politicheskie silyi v postsotsialisticheskih obschestvah: YUgoslaviya / E. YU. Guskova // Obschestvennyie nauki i sovremennost. - 1992. - № 4. - S. 146-157.
Deley YA. Vyiigrayut li novobrantsyi ot vstupleniya v ES? / Ya. Deley // Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya. - 2002. - № 9. - S. 67-71.
Demidov A. M. Sotsiokulturnyie stili v TSentralnoy i Vostochnoy Evrope / A. M. Demidov // Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya. - 1998. - № 4. - S. 16-28.
Dovjenko N. I. Politicheskie silyi v postsotsialisticheskih obschestvah: Rumyiniya / N. I. Dovjenko // Obschestvennyie nauki i sovremennost. - 1992. - № 3. - S. 116-124.
Domіna O. S. Polіtichnі tsіnnostі ta їh sutnіst // Naukoviy chasopis NPU іmenі M. P. Dragomanova. Serіya 22: Polіtichnі nauki ta metodika vikladannya sotsіalno-polіtichnih distsiplіn. - 2014. - Spets. vip. - S. 105-110.
Kіsh Є. Polіtichnі tsіnnostі gromadyanskogo suspіlstva Ugorschini // Naukovі zapiski ІPІEND іm. І. F. Kurasa NAN Ukraїni. - 2014. - Vip. 4-5. - S. 362-376.
Kontler L. Istoriya Vengrii: tyisyacheletie v tsentre Evropyi / L. Kontler. - Moskva: Ves mir, 2002. - 656 s. - (Natsionalnaya istoriya).
Korovitsyina N. V. CHeshskaya identichnost: ob osobennostyah adaptatsii k peremenam / N. V. Korovitsyina // Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya. - 2006. - № 9. - S. 102-109.
Korovitsyina N. V. CHeshskaya sotsiologiya o realnom sostoyanii obschestva i vnov o ego “chelovecheskom litse” / N. V. Korovitsyina // Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya. - 2003. - № 5. - S. 20-29.
Krapivin A. V. Transformatsiya politicheskogo rejima v Bolgarii (konets 80-h - 90-e gg. XX v.) / A. V. Krapivin // Granі іstorії. - 2008. - S. 194-203.
Kudrov V. M. TSentralnaya i Vostochnaya Evropa: desyat let peremen / V. M. Kudrov // Obschestvennyie nauki i sovremennost. - 2001. - № 1. - S. 41-54.
Kulik S. M. Trudnoschі ta problemi vhodjennya Polschі do NATO / S. M. Kulik, Yu. V. Klіmchuk // Naukoviy vіsnik Volinskogo derj. un-tu іm. Lesі Ukraїnki. - 2008. - № 6. - Serіya: Mіjnarodnі vіdnosini. - S. 214-220.
Lavruk T. P. Polіtichnі tsіnnostі yak strategemi funktsіonuvannya polіtichnih prіoritetіv // Panorama polіtologіchnih studіy: Naukoviy vіsnik Rіvnenskogo derjavnogo gumanіtarnogo unіversitetu. - 2013. - Vip. 11. - S. 29-37.
Loshakov A. A. Osnovnyie printsipyi vneshney politiki prezidenta Rumyinii I. Iliesku (1990-1996 gg.) / A. A. Loshakov // Vestnik Nijegorodskogo un-ta im. N. I. Lobachevskogo. - 2008. - № 5. - S. 236-240.
Lyikoshina L. S. “Nitstsa ili smert”: otnoshenie Polshi k proektu Konstitutsii ES / L. S. Lyikoshina // Evropeyskaya bezopasnost: sobyitiya, otsenki, prognozyi. - 2003. - Vyip. 10. - S. 13-16.
Lyasota L. І. Teoretichnі osnovi vivchennya і sotsіalnі mehanіzmi formuvannya sistemi polіtichnih tsіnnostey // Pravova derjava. - 2001. - № 3. - S. 188-192.
Markov D. Politicheskie silyi v postsotsialisticheskih obschestvah: Vengriya / D. Markov // Obschestvennyie nauki i sovremennost. - 1993. - № 1. - S. 142-152.
Markovich D. Ekonomicheskaya elita v transformiruyuschihsya sotsialnyih sistemah / D. Markovich // Vestnik Rossiyskogo un-ta drujbyi narodov. - Seriya: Sotsiologiya. - 2005. - № 1. - S. 5-14.
Marten D. Sotsialnyie izmereniya transformatsii i modernizatsii: teoreticheskie uroki empiricheskih issledovaniy / D. Marten // Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya. - 2002. - № 8. - S. 57-66.
Mіlova M. І. Postkomunіstichna opozitsіya: osoblivostі stanovlennya (na prikladі Bolgarії і Ukraїni) / M. І. Mіlova //
Naukovі pratsі Derjavnogo gumanіtarnogo un-tu іm. P. Mogili. - Serіya: Polіtichnі nauki. - 2005. - T. 44. - S. 104-109.
Pantich D. Konfliktyi tsennostey v stranah tranzitsii / D. Pantich // Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya. - 1997. - № 6. - S. 24-36.
Pehtereva E. A. Ekonomicheskie reformyi v Slovenii// Sotsialnyie i gumanitarnyie nauki: Otechestvennaya i zarubejnaya literatura. - Seriya 2: Ekonomika. - 1995. - № 4. - S. 41-45.
Pravotorova T. V. Novoe i staroe v Polshe pervoy polovinyi 90-h gg. // Sotsialnyie i gumanitarnyie nauki: Otechestvennaya i zarubejnaya literatura. - Seriya 11: Sotsiologiya. - 1997. - № 3. - S. 72-79.
Svetlorusova L. M. [Retsenziya] / L. M. Svetlorusova. - Rets. na kn.: Bolgariya v plenu anomii / J. Vladimirov, T. Todorov, I. Katsarski, M. Badyakov // Sotsialnyie i gumanitarnyie nauki: Otechestvennaya i zarubejnaya literatura. - Seriya 11: Sotsiologiya. - 2000. - № 4. - S. 87-94.
Semenchenko F. G. Polіtichnі tsіnnostі v sistemі polіtichnih vіdnosin: formuvannya, zmіst і funktsії polіtichnih tsіnnostey // Vіsnik Kiїvskogo natsіonalnogo unіversitetu іmenі Tarasa SHevchenka. Serіya: Fіlosofіya. Polіtologіya. - 2010. - Vip. 98. - S. 53-57.
Smirnova N. Rojdenie novoy elityi / N. Smirnova // Novoe vremya. 1996. - № 32. - S. 29-30.
Stoyanovich D. Porochnyiy krug serbskoy oppozitsii / D. Stoyanovich // Serbiya o sebe: sbornik / sost. M. Yovanovich. - Moskva: Evropa, 2005. - S. 115-160.
Subotich M. Sloveniya sredi zvezd / M. Subotich // Stranyi Vostochnoy i YUgo-Vostochnoy Evropyi v poiskah svoey evropeyskoy identichnosti. - Vyip. 9. - Voronej: Voronejskiy gos. un-t; Tsentr izucheniya Tsentralnoy i Vostochnoy Evropyi, 2009. - S. 5-18.
Tarasov I. N. Elektoralnoe izmerenie obrazov politicheskih liderov (na primere stran TSentralno-Vostochnoy Evropyi) // Izvestiya Saratovskogo universiteta. - Seriya: sotsiologiya, politologiya.- 2007. - T. 7. - Vyip. 2. - S. 90-97.
Transformatsiya i modernizatsiya cheshskogo obschestva / P. Mahonin, P. Kuharj, K. Myuller [i dr.] // Sotsiologicheskie issledovaniya. - 2002. - № 7. - S. 32-48.
Scherbakova YU. TSіnnostі ob’ednanoї Evropi. - Kiїv: Akademіya, 2013. - 208 s.
Yanchuk L. Dosvіd realіzatsії єvroіntegratsіynoї strategії Slovatskoї Respublіki// Mіjnarodnі zv’yazki Ukraїni: Naukovі poshuki і znahіdki. - Vip. 18. - Kiїv: Іn-t іstorії Ukraїni NANU, 2009. - S. 159-172.
Yanchuk L. Rol “vishegradskoї solіdarnostі” v zovnіshnopolіtichnіy dіyalnostі Slovatskoї Respublіki (1989-2004 rr.) // Mіjnarodnі zv’yazki Ukraїni: Naukovі poshuki і znahіdki. - Vip. 19. - Kiїv: Іn-t іstorії Ukraini NANU, 2010. - S. 87-96.